Pros and Cons of Web against
BEX
-
Web reporting is faster then Excel, there is less overhead
in executing Web reporting as opposed to Excel. (Whitepaper on SAP about
this.)
-
There is not anymore work in formatting or creation of templates
then in comparison to workbooks.
-
Query creation is the same as in BEX, so there is no new
knowledge there.
-
Yes, knowledge of HTML is needed, but if you use the standard
CSS templates, you really don't need to know them unless you want to change
them. But, if you can write queries or code ABAP, you can definitely learn
basic HTML and CSS to customize reporting. Its not that hard.
-
The learning curve for NEW users in Web Reporting vs.. BEX
is actually considerably lower. Most people are very familiar with using
a web browser, and IMOE I have found they pick up usage of web reporting
much quicker then trying to teach them BEX.
-
Note, if you have a large user base which is already power
Excel/BEx users, then they might be more reluctant to switch, though they
would have no problem learning quickly the web reporting. Their downside
would be that the behavior is not like Excel, which is a learned behavior,
though the functionality is the same.
-
Publishing of queries and reports is done (or can be) via
a role template which can be published on the web to provide common access
to reports and queries.
-
Your implementation team (or at least one person on there)
could be designated to picking up learning creation of web templates. (Its
not hard, really.) Depending on organization size you may not need an additional
person.
-
Publishing can be as easy a link on an existing intranet,
or if you are using Portals already, integration with Portals is straightforward
and you should have the knowledge base for doing so w/ your Portals group.
-
Query functionality is EXACTLY THE SAME with BEX and Web
reporting, they both use query analyzer. The only difference is in presentation
and output.
-
With Web reporting, you have (I think) greater control over
presentation (combination of reports, charts, etc...) then w/ BEX.
-
You can provide the ability for "Printer friendly" versions
of web reports, you can also provide the ability to easily pull the results
into Excel in standard format or CSV format.
-
Finally, I think you have the ability to open up reporting
and information consumption to a wider audience then in sticking w/ just
BEx. (It definitely has its place in the organization.)
Also read
Get help for your SAP BW problems
SAP
BW Forum - Do you have a SAP BW Question?
SAP Business Warehouse Books
SAP BW
Books - Certification, Interview Questions and Configuration
Best regards,
SAP Basis, ABAP Programming and Other IMG Stuff
http://www.erpgreat.com
All the site contents are Copyright © www.erpgreat.com
and the content authors. All rights reserved.
All product names are trademarks of their respective
companies. The site www.erpgreat.com is in no way affiliated with
SAP AG.
Every effort is made to ensure the content integrity.
Information used on this site is at your own risk.
The content on this site may not be reproduced
or redistributed without the express written permission of
www.erpgreat.com or the content authors.
|